Served Improperly with a Summons and Complaint? Move to Dismiss within 60 Days!

New York law is strict when it comes to preserving — and acting upon — a defense grounded on improper service. In a nutshell, and subject to other rules (which I invite you to contact me about), valid service of a summons on an individual occurs through:

  1. personal delivery;
  2. delivery to another person in your current home or business with follow-up mailing;
  3. affixing a copy to the door of your current home or business with follow-up mailing;
  4. delivery to a designated agent; or
  5. by any other manner that the court may direct.[1]

If you take the position that service was not carried out properly, you must either make a timely pre-answer motion to dismiss the complaint, or alternatively, raise it as an affirmative defense in your answer and make a follow-up motion to dismiss the case within 60 days of serving the answer.

The court strictly enforces this rule. To seek an extension of that 60-day deadline you must establish "undue hardship," which appears to be a very strict standard. Protect yourself and make the motion to dismiss early!

See our prior blog, Legal Grounds for a Motion to Dismiss.



[1] CPLR § 308. Read the section for all of its requirements.

Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.